Blog

Complying with ONC Information Blocking Under 45 CFR Part 171

A practical guide to 45 CFR Part 171 information blocking rules, the eight statutory exceptions, and chart-release protocols for independent medical practices.

By Shant M Hambarsoumian, Whadata

Complying with ONC Information Blocking Under 45 CFR Part 171

The 21st Century Cures Act established a legal presumption that electronic health information must be shared, not withheld. Codified under 45 CFR Part 171, the Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC) regulations define information blocking as any practice by an actor, including healthcare providers, that is likely to interfere with, prevent, or materially discourage access, exchange, or use of electronic health information (EHI). For independent medical practices, adhering to these mandates requires shifting from a policy of releasing records only upon formal request to an operational posture of immediate, friction-free clinical data sharing.

Understanding Information Blocking Under 45 CFR Part 171

The statutory framework applies to healthcare providers, health IT developers, and health information networks. A provider violates the rule if they know that their practice is unreasonable and likely to impede the flow of EHI. In daily operations, this covers common administrative habits: delaying the release of lab results until a physician reviews them, charging excessive fees for digital chart transfers, or requiring patients to submit notarized paper forms before granting portal access.

Achieving information blocking compliance medical practice leaders can rely on requires treating all EHI defined under the United States Core Data for Interoperability (USCDI) standard as immediately accessible by default. When a request for clinical data arrives from a patient, another clinician, or a designated third-party application, the practice must fulfill it without contractual, technical, or administrative roadblocks.

The Eight Regulatory Exceptions

The regulations acknowledge that clinical data cannot be shared unconditionally in every scenario. The ONC established eight specific exceptions divided into two distinct classes: exceptions that involve not fulfilling requests for EHI, and exceptions that involve procedures for fulfilling requests. To avoid a penalty, a practice withholding data must satisfy every condition of an applicable exception.

Class 1: Exceptions That Involve Not Fulfilling Requests

1. Preventing Harm: This exception permits withholding EHI if the provider reasonably believes that releasing the information will substantially lessen a risk of physical harm to a patient or another person. The determination must be based on an individualized clinical assessment. A blanket policy withholding sensitive diagnoses does not qualify.

2. Privacy: A practice is not required to disclose EHI if doing so is prohibited by state or federal privacy laws, such as HIPAA, or if specific consent requirements under state law have not been met despite reasonable efforts to obtain them.

3. Security: Providers may withhold data to safeguard the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of EHI, provided the security measure is implemented in a non-discriminatory manner and directly addresses a recognized security risk.

4. Infeasibility: A practice may decline a request if legitimate uncontrollable circumstances prevent fulfillment. These circumstances include natural disasters, technological unavailability beyond the provider's control, or the inability to segment the requested EHI from records that cannot legally be disclosed. The practice must provide a written response explaining why the request is infeasible within ten business days of receipt.

5. Health IT Performance: An actor may temporarily make health IT offline to perform maintenance, upgrades, or system fixes, provided the downtime meets specific duration and notification criteria.

Class 2: Exceptions That Involve Procedures for Fulfilling Requests

6. Content and Manner: This exception governs how a practice must respond when it cannot provide EHI in the exact format requested. The practice must first attempt to use alternative consensus-based standards or mutually agreed-upon formats before asserting that an exchange cannot occur.

7. Fees: Practices may charge reasonable, cost-based fees for certain EHI access requests, but they cannot assess fees for electronic access via patient portals or standard APIs, nor can they price fees to deter data exchange.

8. Licensing: Providers and developers may license interoperability elements under reasonable and non-discriminatory terms to ensure intellectual property protections while enabling technical integration.

Establishing Practice Protocols for Chart Release

Independent compliance officers must translate these federal definitions into written standard operating procedures. Policies that enforce mandatory delays on clinical notes, pathology reports, or diagnostic imaging must be discontinued immediately. Modern practice systems must be configured to release notes, lab results, and vitals to the patient portal as soon as they are finalized in the system of record.

When a provider determines that an exception applies, the medical justification must be entered directly into the patient chart at the time of the decision. For instance, invoking the Preventing Harm exception requires documenting the specific clinical basis for potential physical injury. Compliance teams must periodically audit denied data requests to verify that each instance aligns with statutory definitions.

Monitoring Enforcement Timelines and Disincentives

Enforcement mechanisms carry significant financial ramifications. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of Inspector General (OIG) investigates allegations of information blocking, while the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) establishes disincentives for healthcare providers. These disincentives include downward adjustments under the Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS) and exclusion from the Medicare Shared Savings Program.

Because administrative rules, technical standards, and enforcement rollouts evolve across federal rulemakings, clinicians and administrators should check ONC announcements directly for active enforcement timelines. Staying updated through direct regulatory bulletins prevents your clinic from relying on outdated transition periods or misinterpreting statutory effective dates.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can our clinic hold lab results until the ordering physician reviews them with the patient? No. Holding results until a physician consultation occurs violates 45 CFR Part 171 unless the clinician specifically documents an individualized risk of physical harm under the Preventing Harm exception.

Does information blocking apply to paper records? No. The rule applies strictly to electronic health information. However, HIPAA right of access provisions still govern paper chart release timelines and fees.

What should we do if another clinic asks us to fax records? While electronic exchange via direct secure messaging or interoperable health record networks is preferred, practices should fulfill valid requests using the requested format, including outbound fax, rather than refusing the exchange.

Ready to Transform Your Practice?